Cameroonian Dentists’ Opinion On Training And Quality Of Dental Services Rendered By Dental Auxiliaries
Authors: Agbor MA1 (BDS, MSc. Dent), Azodo CC2 (BDS, MSc, MPH) 1-Dental Department, Nkwen Baptist Health Centre, Bamenda,
Cameroon 2-Department of Periodontics, University of Benin Teaching Hospital, Nigeria. Corresponding author: Dr C.C. Azodo, Department of Periodontics. University of Benin Teaching Hospital New Dental Complex P.M.B 1111 Ugbowo Benin-City, Edo State Nigeria 300001. E-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org Phone: +2348034051699
To assess Cameroonian dentists’ opinion on training and quality of dental services rendered by dental auxiliaries.
Material and Methods:
The questionnaire-based cross-sectional survey was conducted amongst randomly selected dentists from six provinces in Cameroon in the first quarter of 2010.
More than half (51.4%) of the 37 respondents have worked with den-tal auxiliaries for more than 4 years with higher interaction between the respondents and dental therapists (59.5%). Majority approved scaling and polishing and tooth extraction, few approved root canal therapy and none approved minor surgical procedure like salivary stone removal for the dental auxiliaries. Most respondents (86.5%) agreed that dental auxiliaries work well with 30 (81.1%) opining that the quality of services rendered by the dental auxiliaries were very sat-isfactory. A total of 15 (41%) of the respondents thought that dental therapists should work in specific areas with 80% recommending rural areas. Majority of the respondents 30 (81.1%) thought that dental auxiliaries are important in oral health care delivery in Cameroon and 33 (89.2%) of the respondents thought that government should continue the training of dental auxiliaries.
The study revealed high level of interactions between dentists and dental auxiliaries in Cameroon. The respondents’ opinions about den-tal auxiliaries were mostly positive. There existed variability in opinion of respondents about procedures that dental auxiliaries should per-form. The is need for establishment of regulatory agency which would tap and harmonize all the derivable potential from dental auxiliaries.
Cameroon is a Central African country with a 2009 esti-mated population of 18.9 million people and a popula-tion growth rate of 2.19% (1). The country’s per-capita GDP was estimated as US$ 2,300 in 2008. It has no den-tal school and only 147 actively practicing dentists reg-istered with Cameroon Dental Association. The DMFT among 12 year olds is higher than many other African countries (2). With the growing population, limited resources, shortage of manpower and an abundance of dental diseases, services of dental auxiliaries are greatly needed to help meet the demand for services.
Utilization of dental auxiliary personnel is necessary for the provision of adequate oral health services to meet societal demands. By performing jobs formally handled by dentists, the auxiliary worker frees the dentist for complex tasks and thereby ensures a greater total sup-ply of services. The greater use of paraprofessionals has resulted in greater outputs of services by professionals in Dentistry, Medicine and Law (3). It has been found from research that dentists work more efficiently and ef -
fectively using these auxiliaries in their dental practice (4-6). In private dental surgeries in Kenya, improving the efficiency in patient’s management was the main reason for the utilization of dental auxiliaries (5).
The objective of the study was to assess the dentist’s opinion on quality of dental services and training of dental auxiliaries in Cameroon.
Materials and Methods
This research was conducted as a descriptive cross-sectional survey of dentists working in six provinces in Cameroon. The list of registered dentists obtained from Cameroon Dental Association showed that 143 out of 147 dentists in Cameroon work in the six provinces. Ev-ery third dentist from the list of registered dentists in the six provinces was selected using systematic sampling technique. A total of 47 questionnaires were adminis-tered and 37 dentists responded giving an overall re-sponse rate of 78.7%.
The 37 dentists that responded had a mean age of 38
± 10 years. Age range was 27-57 years; 14 females and
23 males. Of the 37 dentists, 32 (86.5%) worked in ur-ban areas while 5 (13.5%) worked in the rural areas. A self-administered bilingual (English and French) ques-tionnaire was used to collect information on demog-raphy, the type of auxiliaries working with them, their satisfaction with the work of auxiliaries under their su-pervision, areas of dissatisfaction with the work, areas therapist should be assign to work, whether they should work alone, and if more of them should be trained and their recommendations. Ethical clearance to carry out the study was obtained from the respective provincial organs of the Cameroonian Ministry of Public Health in the six provinces. Informed consent was obtained from the participants after being informed of the objective of the study and assured of strict confidentiality of their responses. Participation was voluntary and no incentive was declared. Epi-info version Epi 3.1.5 was used for data analysis. Test for significance was performed using Chi square. P≤0.05 was considered significant.
The proportion of the respondents who had worked with dental auxiliaries, dental therapists, dental surgery assistants, dental technicians and dental aids was 100%, 59.5%, 43.2%, 45.9% and 5.4% respectively (Fig. 1). More than half (51.4%) of the respondents had worked with auxiliaries for more than 4 years. Others had worked for 4 years (18.9%), 3 years (16.2%), 2 years 4 (10.8%) and unspecified duration (2.7%, n = 1). Most (81.1%) of the respondents ( n = 30) opined that the quality of services rendered by the dental auxiliaries was very satis-factory (Figure 2). All the respondents did not approve auxiliaries carrying out minor surgery while 24 (64.9%) and 6 (16.2%) of them (64.9%) did not approve auxilia-ries performing root canal therapy and tooth extraction respectively (Table 1).
About one-third, 12 (32.4%) of the respondents had the impression that dental auxiliaries are important (Table 2). Most of the respondents (86.5%) agreed that dental auxiliaries work well and 15 (41%) of the respondents thought that dental therapists should work in specific ar-eas with 80% recommending rural areas. Some respon-dents (43.2%) approved that dental auxiliaries should be allowed to work alone. Thirty respondents thought that dental auxiliaries were important in oral health care delivery in Cameroon and thirty three supported con-tinued training of dental auxiliaries by the government
Click to view figure 2
Teamwork is essential for the provision of contempo-rary, high quality oral health care (7). The present trend in dentistry is toward increased auxiliary utilization and improved methods in the delivery of health care. The experiences of majority of the respondents with differ-ent categories of dental auxiliaries reflect the significance of dental auxiliaries in the oral healthcare delivery and applicability of teamwork in Cameroon oral healthcare delivery. The increased interactions with dental thera-pists may be due to their valuable role in preventing oral diseases by performing meticulous scaling and polishing and oral hygiene instructions (8).
Dental auxiliaries are able to provide dental care of ac-ceptable quality. The efficient utilization of dental aux-iliaries usually results in decreased cost and increased productivity for the community. In this study, 86.5%
Majority of the respondents ap-proved scaling and polishing and
tooth extraction, few approved root canal therapy and none ap-proved minor surgical procedure like salivary stone removal for dental auxiliaries. Variability of the opinions of the respondents on procedures that can be per-formed by the dental auxiliaries reflects the diversity in the train-ing of the respondents as all the dentists in Cameroon are trained in different countries of the world. In private dental surgeries in Ke-nya, delegation was done primar-ily based on dental auxiliaries’ ca-pability to perform the procedure and meet the set standards (5). This reflects an obvious need for a consensus among the dentists in order to standardize the job description of dental auxiliaries and establish a dental auxiliary regula-tory agency in the long run.
Dental auxiliaries are valuable members of the dental care team and play a significant role for oral healthcare delivery. A signifi-cant proportion (81.1%) of the respondents agreed that dental auxiliaries were important in oral healthcare delivery in Cameroon
agreed that respondents work well and 81.1% declared the quality of services rendered by dental auxiliaries as very satisfactory. Earlier reports have indicated that irre-versible dental treatment carried out by dental therapists did not differ from that of dentists (10). A review more than 3 decades ago showed that dental auxiliaries can, with the proper training, perform selected reversible and irreversible dental procedures at an acceptable level of quality (10). which may be the reason why 89.2% the respondents supported their continued training. Almost half the dentists (41%) believe auxiliaries should work in a specific locality because of the needs with 80% suggesting working in rural areas. This may compensate the inequi-table distribution of dental manpower. More than half 56.8 % of the respondents agreed operative auxiliaries like therapists should work under supervision and sus-tained training. This is lower than 84% of general dental practitioner in Udaipur, India who thought that direct supervision was necessary although the reasons for that were not sought in that research (7).
The study revealed high level of interactions between dentist and dental auxiliaries in Cameroon.
The respondents’ opinions about dental auxiliaries were mostly positive. There existed variability in opinion of respondents about procedures that dental auxiliaries should perform. There is need for establishment of regu-latory agency which would harmonize all the derivable potential from dental auxiliaries.
Wikipedia. Demographics of Cameroon. http://en.wikipedia. org/wiki/Demographics_of_Cameroon. Accessed 01\01\10
WHO Oral Health Country/Area Profile Programme. Glob-al Caries burden for 12-year-old age group. http://www. whocollab.od.mah.se/afro.html. Accessed 01\01\10
MacBride O. Restrictive licensing of dental paraprofessionals. Yale Law Journal. 1974; 83: 806-826.
Amer ME. Use of operating dental auxiliaries for school age children. University of Sydney Diploma in Public Health Dentistry Thesis. 1986.
Kaimenyi JT, Guthua SW, Wakiaga J, et al. Utilization of den-tal auxiliaries in private dental surgeries in Kenya. East Afr Med J. 1994; 71(12):811-5.
Gercsak JR. A study of job satisfaction and turnover of den-tal auxiliaries in British Columbia. Simon Fraser University Master of Business Administration (MBA) Thesis 1976.
Kulkarni S, Jain M, Mathur A, et al. General dental practi-tioners knowledge and attitudes towards employing dental hygienist or surgery assistant in India. The Internet J of Dent Sc. 2009 Number 1.
Ohrn K. The role of dental hygienists in oral health preven-tion. Oral Health Prev Dent. 2004; 2 Suppl 1:277-81.
Bolin K A. Assessment of treatment provided by dental health aide therapist in Alaska. A pilot study. J Am Dent As-soc. 2008; 139 (12):1585.
Sisty NL, Henderson WG, Paule CL. Review of training and evaluation studies in expanded functions for dental auxilia-ries. J Am Dent Assoc. 1979; 98(2):233-48.